The Causes and Effects of High Gas Prices
Note: There is now a companion page about
The Causes and Effects of High Oil Prices,
which deals with the crude oil supply, the worldwide market, the controversy over offshore
drilling, refinery capacity and many other issues.
Much has been said about high gas prices recently, starting in 2005
after Hurricane Katrina hit
New Orleans and the retail price of gasoline spiked for a few weeks. But the
price of gas has a number of causes and effects that aren't discussed in any great
detail on TV news shows. (Other than sports and weather, nothing is discussed in
much detail on television, but
that's another story.) This page represents an attempt to fill in the gaps.
Radical environmentalists and their friends in the news
media would have you believe that high gas prices are primarily the result of corporate greed,
poor planning, and insufficient government intervention. In reality, this is a matter of supply
and demand, and it is not the proper role of government to intervene.
The major causes of high gas prices include the increased demand for oil in places
like China and India, high gasoline taxes, civil unrest in Venezuela, war in the
Middle East, political instability in Nigeria, and too few refineries in the U.S. Demand
is kept high (in part) by people who prefer the comfort and safety of large trucks and SUV's
regardless of their lower fuel economy. If
they can afford the gas, I support their freedom to choose any vehicle they want. But
a huge part of the supply problem is due
to environmental regulations (and environmentalists'
opposition to new refineries), and
political opposition to oil exploration in the Gulf of Mexico and
in parts of Alaska.
Gasoline supplies are impeded by regulations that require specialized blends of gasoline for certain
parts of the country. Gasoline used to be essentially the same nationwide, but there are many different
"flavors" of gas sold now, in some cases for specific counties. Generally this seems to cause the
price of gas to be higher in and around big cities.
One reason for the surge in gas prices during the early summer months is the number of people who drive to their
vacation destinations. More and more people are driving, I think, because of what they would have
to go
through at the airport, just to
travel 400 miles.
Some people think the oil companies make astronomical profits. But if you really believe that's
true, you should keep quiet and buy stock in ExxonMobil! I challenge you to buy a barrel of
crude oil and see if you can make gasoline out of it for less than $10.00 a gallon.
If you find gas prices unaffordable, and if you don't mind squeezing into a crowded bus or
train with a bunch of smelly and nasty strangers, you might
consider mass transit as
an alternative.
Gasoline is a bargain at $4.00 a gallon. Get used to it. Driving a car is a
luxury for which we should be grateful. And don't get your hopes up
about Ethanol, because that's
not the perfect solution either.
When you're finished here, check out
the Oil and Gas section of the
Environmental False Alarms page.
First of all, the price of everything is going up.
Prices of OJ, Milk and Gas Skyrocket.
Mornings for Americans are about to get a lot more expensive: The prices of orange juice, milk and
gas are spiking and all are expected to go even higher.
Sticker shock at the grocery as soaring wheat
prices mean more expensive food. If you think the cost of gassing up your car is outrageous,
wait until you need to restock your pantry. The price of wheat has more than tripled in the U.S. during
the past 10 months, making Americans' daily bread — and bagels and pizza and pasta — feel
a little like luxury items. Baked goods aren't the only ones getting more expensive: Experts
expect 80 percent of grocery prices will spike too, and could remain steep for years.
Gasoline Prices: Increases in retail
gasoline prices from 2000 until fall 2006, and their sudden decline in September of that year, led to claims
of price manipulation by oil companies, with Democrats accusing Republicans of being "in the pockets" of oil
and gas companies. In fact, gasoline prices at their peak only matched their inflation-adjusted prices
of the 1980s, and oil industry profits, while large in dollar terms, are not higher than the profit rates
reported by other industries. Repeated investigations of oil industry practices have failed to find
evidence of price-fixing or anti-competitive behavior.
The
Real Reason Gasoline Costs More: The popular myth about Big Oil is that it wields such great
power that nation states cannot resist them. The reality is that, faced with dictators like [Hugo] Chavez,
often the only alternative is to leave or cut the best deal they can. The other reality is that Venezuela's
oil production has declined 25 percent since Chavez, a committed Communist, crushed the strike. With
the major oil companies departing, how much greater a decline lies ahead? That is just one reason
gasoline will cost more.
Find the lowest gas prices in your zip code.
State-by-state gasoline averages from AAA.
Federal Gasoline Excise Tax
Rate, 1932-2007.
Gas prices state-by-state (Map)
More Oil and Gas News.
Gas Buddy can help you find cheap gas prices in your
city. It is a network of more than 179+ gas price information web sites that helps you find
low gasoline prices.
Truckers protesting high fuel
prices. Independent truckers around the country pulled their rigs off the road and others slowed
to a crawl on major highways in a loosely organized protest of high fuel prices. Some truckers, on CB radios
and trucking Web sites, had called for a strike Tuesday to protest the high cost of diesel fuel
.
Bush and Congress Should Lift Environmental Restrictions on Energy
Production. With American consumers currently paying the highest gasoline prices in recent history, and after
another winter of high heating costs, many Americans are properly concerned about America's energy future. Predictably,
many politicians and commentators blame the "greed" of U.S. energy companies for the soaring prices. The truth, however,
is that prices rise when demand increases relative to supply, and that the American supply of energy is being strangled by
the policies of U.S. federal and state governments.
Astonishing!
Gas Shenanigans: During this
unprecedented increase in oil and gas prices,
we, the United States, are allowing the sale of gasoline refined
domestically. That's right
we're sending gasoline out of the country. The very same gas, is
refined here, then shipped to Mexico — where subsidies put in place by the Mexican government allow Mexican
citizens to purchase gas at half the price Americans pay.
High gas prices lead to
surge in mass transit. It's standing-room-only on many commuter buses from Washington's suburbs.
Rail systems from Boston to Los Angeles are begging passengers to shift their travel to non-peak hours.
And some seats have been removed from San Francisco's subway cars to allow more people to cram in.
Around the country, high gas prices are helping to push more people to leave their cars at home and crowd
onto trains, buses and subways.
More information
about Mass Transit and Car Pooling .
What makes up the
price of gas? Once oil is pumped from the ground, it can be sold on the spot market, a last-minute trading
arena where oil companies and distributors buy and sell to each other, or straight to refiners. After it's brewed into
gasoline, the product can again be sold on the spot market, or directly to wholesalers, who in turn can supply their own
stations or sell it to other retailers. Each step of the way, buyers and sellers negotiate a price until, finally,
drivers pay the ultimate tab at the pump.
Gas prices
blame game: [Scroll down] It's also worth noting that oil companies are probably the most investigated
companies in America. Every few years, outraged legislators demand that the Federal Trade Commission determine whether
oil companies are colluding to inflate prices. Repeatedly, federal regulators find that they aren't.
Republican
talks fuel prices; Dems tout their agendas. Sen. John McCain on Tuesday [4/15/2008] called for a
summer-long suspension of the federal gasoline tax and several tax cuts. To help people weather the
economic downturn immediately, the Republican presidential nominee-in-waiting urged Congress to institute a
"gas-tax holiday" by suspending the 18.4 cent federal gas tax and 24.4 cent diesel tax from Memorial
Day to Labor Day.
Global Warming
Holiday: Most of the price of gasoline is determined by the global price of crude oil, which is spiking now
due to a combination of the weak dollar and commodity speculation. The source of the problem isn't the tax. Domestic
demand for gas always goes up with summer driving, but the McCain holiday doesn't affect production, and anyway, only
applies over the short term. More notably, it makes a hash out of the climate-change policies that the candidate
purports to favor.
Shell Oil president: To cut price,
produce more gasoline in U.S.. John Hofmeister, president of Shell Oil Co., the U.S. division of
Royal Dutch Shell, addressed rising gasoline prices during an interview Wednesday [4/30/2008] with John Roberts
on CNN's "American Morning."
"I say we need more gas to be produced in this country. I've been
saying that for three years, ever since I took this position [as president of Shell]. If the U.S. set a
goal to produce 2 to 3 million barrels more a day in this country, we would send a shock around the
world that would immediately say to the speculators, hey, U.S. is serious."
Aging refineries drive price
at the pump. It is not ExxonMobil or Middle Eastern oil producers
who are driving the price of gasoline you pay at the pump. It is shortages of gas and other problems at
aging refineries in your neighborhoods.
Group trying to stop BP refinery
expansion. The Natural Resources Defense Council filed a federal court appeal Wednesday [7/9/2008],
alleging that BP Whiting's air permit will allow an expanded refinery to emit substantially more pollution
than the Clean Air Act allows. The environmental group hopes the lawsuit will send BP and the Indiana
Department of Environmental Management back to the drawing board to draft a new, more stringent permit.
Environmental Group Sues to Block
Oil Refinery Expansion. An environmental group on Wednesday filed a lawsuit intended to stop the
expansion of a BP oil refinery in Whiting, Indiana. A shortage of oil refining capacity is often
mentioned as one reason for soaring gasoline prices.
Gas
could fall to $2 if Congress acts, analysts say. The price of retail gasoline could fall by half,
to around $2 a gallon, within 30 days of passage of a law to limit speculation in energy-futures markets, four
energy analysts told Congress on Monday [6/23/2008].
Who Is Really Responsible For The
High Prices You Pay For Gasoline? For the last 28 years, Democrats in Congress and a few
Republicans have again and again opposed our drilling for oil in Alaska's ANWR area when we knew it contained
at least 10 billion barrels of oil we could be using now. For the past 31 years, Congress
repeatedly prevented us from building any new oil refineries that we now badly need. More recently,
congressional Democrats defeated and discouraged any bill that would let us drill in the deep sea 100 miles
out. However, it's somehow OK for China to drill there.
Top 10 reasons to blame Democrats
for soaring gasoline prices: If Bill Clinton had signed into law the Republican Congress's 1995
bill to allow drilling of ANWR instead of vetoing it, ANWR could be producing a million barrels of (non-Opec)
oil a day — 5% of the nation's consumption. Although speaking in another context, even Democrat Senator
Charles Schumer, no proponent of ANWR drilling, admits that "one million barrels per day," would cause the
price of gasoline to fall "50 cents a gallon almost immediately," according to a recent George Will column.
Turn up the heat on Congress to bring gas
prices down. Senators and representatives know there is growing anger and frustration in the
body politick over rising gas prices. They know their excuses for inaction are not flying with the
public, says the editor and founder of WND. Joseph Farah is taking the unusual action of launching
an ad hoc political movement in the waning days of the second session of the 110th Congress.
Blame Democrats for high gas prices. Two
years ago then Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi boldly proclaimed, "Democrats have a common-sense plan to help bring down
skyrocketing gas prices." Since she became speaker of the House, gas prices have skyrocketed from about $2.33 per
gallon to $3.85 as I write this.
Energy a Democratic minus?
Gasoline prices are flattening consumer wallets and hobbling our economy, while the Democrats sit back and play politics
with the issue. Voter surveys show the economy and gas prices top the list of the most critical issues facing our
country. A Washington Post/ABC News poll reported last week that 85 percent of voters polled said
gas prices will be either extremely or very important to their vote in this year's elections.
Drivers blame
D.C. for high gas prices. Fed up with record gas prices, drivers often scapegoat big oil
companies for high prices at the pump, but in a recent survey, more Americans directed their scorn towards
Washington lawmakers. According to a Consumer Reports Auto Pulse Survey released Thursday [6/26/2008],
77% of consumers said the root of high gas prices lies with the government's failure to implement an
effective energy policy.
Cussin' At The Pump Won't Fix The
Problem. These days, each gas station and each grocery store receipt shows American citizens
how much they are paying for politicians who sold out to radical environmentalists and liberal social
engineers. That's the cost of bad political leadership. How so? Since the 1970s, liberal
politicians in Congress have passed laws that have locked up most of our oil reserves, stopped the
construction of refineries and virtually banned the building of nuclear power plants. Every time we buy
food, pump fuel or pay a natural gas or electric bill, we pay a price for these foolish policy decisions.
What's not to like?
Time magazine's recent piece "10 Things You Can Like About $4 Gas" exposes the twisted thinking of watermelons
(green on the outside, Red on the inside). While acknowledging Americans' only recourse today is to
"adapt just by suffering," the article celebrates the benefits of record gasoline prices.
Democrats Float Bill to Curb Gasoline
Demand. Anxious to look like they're doing something about rising oil and gas prices — but
unwilling to expand domestic oil drilling — Democrats have introduced a bill that's supposed to ease pain at
the pump by offering alternatives to driving. The bill does nothing to increase domestic energy supply.
Fossil Fool. As
pressure builds to develop America's domestic energy resources, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid now says
it's a health issue. Coal and oil, he says, make us sick. So why does he oppose nuclear power?
How much have the
Democrats cost you at the pump? Senator Chuck Schumer claims that coercing Saudi Arabia to
increase oil production by 1 million barrels a day would drop the per barrel price by $25, saving
Americans 62 cents per gallon at the gas pump. Yet, somehow, that same amount of oil coming from
Alaska's Arctic National Wildlife Refuge would only ease oil prices by a penny.
When
You Fill Up the Tank Thank Congress for High Gas Prices. Left-wingers want to have their cake and eat it too, of course:
they simultaneously insist that oil is running out, its use is ruining our environment and should stop as soon as possible,
and that oil gas should still be cheap at the pump.
How stupid do they think we are? How is it possible to
simultaneously wean ourselves from oil and the carbon dioxide emissions that stems from it, keep oil cheap and abundant,
drill for oil absolutely nowhere, and sue oil companies without hurting consumers? Oh, and don't forget to slap
a "windfall profits" tax on the oil companies just for good measure.
Ball Squarely In Congress'
Court. If this "lame duck" president succeeds in exposing this do-nothing Congress'
self-serving pettiness in the midst of so much consumer pain at the pump, things might not turn out as
badly for Republicans this November as the pundits predict.
The Marxist tactic of Crisis
revolution: The current revolutionary cry is to tax the "greedy," American-owned oil companies for their
"wind-fall" profits. In much the same way that [Bill] Clinton spoke of gun companies in the 1990s, today's Democrats
demean oil companies with their "shame on you for what you're doing to the American people" approach, while simultaneously
refusing to allow domestic drilling, to increase offshore drilling, or to drill in ANWR. Like Clinton, the
Congressional Democrats, who have created the current crisis, will allow a certain degree of suffering on the part
of the people in order to insure their agenda is furthered.
Dems
Skip Town: Empty Promises Revealed. Right now middle-class Americans are suffering from
expensive-energy induced inflation. We all know the adverse consequences pain at the pumps has wrought.
So what does "the most open" House majority of all time do when a fair and honest debate over drilling doesn't
exactly help them? They dodge the debate for weeks. They disingenuously lead the American people
to believe that oil and gas won't necessarily be a part of our energy needs in the future.
Fueling a Furor: Beyond
the finger-pointing, it's important for Americans to understand that America's "big oil" industry did not
place us in our current predicament. Congress and state legislatures — with the aid of
special interests groups — are largely to blame. The inescapable reality is that our nation
needs and uses a lot of energy. And without policies that encourage increased domestic production of
energy, fuel will get even more expensive.
Too "Complex"?
The problem is not that supply and demand is such a complex explanation. The problem is that supply and
demand is not an emotionally satisfying explanation. For that, you need melodrama, heroes and villains.
It is clear that many people prefer to blame President Bush. Others prefer to blame the oil companies, who
have long been the favorite villains of the left. Politicians understand that.
Common glitch at pump adds to gas costs, also cheats station.
Angry about the price of gas? Just imagine paying for gas you don't get. Some alert consumers have noticed it
over the years: A pump that seems to hesitate a second when the lever is squeezed. Anywhere from 2 to
6 cents tick off before the rush of gasoline starts. That's what happens with a common, hard to diagnose and
mostly ignored problem with the "check valve," which is supposed to make sure gas flows at the same time the price
meter starts. But even if your gas pump works, it can still be off as much as $5 for every fill up. Tests by
local regulators allow a pump to charge as much as 6 cents more than the gas delivered in a five-gallon test.
As gas nears
$4, Minneapolis eyes limits on engine idling. Minneapolis City Council members today [5/15/2008]
will hear from city staff members about a proposed ordinance to restrict vehicle idling in most cases to
3 minutes.
Update:
Minneapolis limits vehicle idling to three minutes.
The Minneapolis City Council and Mayor R.T. Rybak approved changes Friday [6/6/2008], to the city's vehicle idling
ordinance that aims to reduce air pollution. The ordinance limits mostvehicle idling to three minutes, except in
traffic.
Should Madison ban the
drive-through? First it was a proposed ban on plastic bags. Now, a member of the
influential Madison Plan Commission wants to ban the restaurant drive-through — or at least
restrict the ubiquitous symbol of America's auto-centric lifestyle. "Given the concern about all the
carbon going into the atmosphere, I'm not sure we should be building more places for people to sit idling in
their cars," says Eric Sundquist, who was appointed to the citizen panel by Mayor Dave Cieslewicz this
spring.
Chicanery alert!
There is a big difference between "carbon going into the atmosphere" and carbon dioxide going
into the atmosphere.
Gas thefts are on the rise.
A New Way to Guzzle Gas: In the past the most
common form of fuel theft was to drive away from the station without paying. Station owners have fought
back in recent years by forcing drivers to pay before fueling. These days 99 percent of the nation's
million-plus pumps have that requirement, according to the NACS.
Because of the prepayment requirement,
thieves have had to devise more creative schemes.
Thieves Find Easy,
Lucrative Work In Siphoning Fuel From Cars, Stations. With average prices of more than $4 a gallon for
unleaded and $5 for diesel fuel, siphoning has become an easy and profitable crime of opportunity, officials said.
Pilfering gas requires little more than a hose and a container, although the low-tech method might involve a mouthful of
fuel to get the flow going.
U-Haul: Crooked renters refill gas tank with
water. Crooks have come up with a new scam to get out of paying for gas, and it's costing truck
rental companies thousands of dollars. Crooks reportedly rent U-Haul trucks then, when the time comes to
return the truck, top off the tank with water instead of gas, wrecking the engine. U-Haul dealers say
the scam has become more prevalent as gas prices continue to rise.
Take
it from UPS: Left turns waste gas. UPS routes are designed to avoid left turns. Idling
while waiting to turn left wastes time and gas. This tip shaved 29 million miles off its U.S. drivers'
routes last year, saving UPS more than 3 million gallons of gas.
At $9 per gallon, British driving habits
change. Pump nozzle in hand, Lisa Atkins keeps a close eye on the digital display rapidly
adding up the pounds. Gone are the days when she'd routinely fill the gas tank to the brim. She
now has to be more cautious.
House Republicans vow push on oil
drilling. With the November congressional and presidential elections looming, Republicans and Democrats in the
U.S. House of Representatives are blaming each other for rising energy costs and gasoline prices that are topping $4 a
gallon. Republicans cited Democratic opposition to opening up the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge and more offshore
areas to oil and gas exploration and drilling.
The
Moral Imperative for Drilling: The other day in a poor part of Central California, I talked with
a number of folks at a rural gas station. Most drove second- and third-hand pickups, large cast-off sedans
or used SUVs. They didn't have the cash to buy a new fuel-efficient Honda or Toyota. And they were
now spending a day or two of their wages just to fuel their cars.
Congress,
Get Off Your Gas, and Drill. With gas at $4 per gallon, roughly two cars in every household,
and the average annual gas usage at 700 gallons, you do the math. Americans are being forced to use their
hard-earned money that once put food in their stomachs to put petroleum in their tanks and to drive the exact
same distances they drove a decade ago for four to five times the price.
Senators Warn Bill Could Spike
Gas $1.50 to $5 a Gallon. Worried about gas prices hitting $4 a gallon and beyond? Imagine
if they were $6, $7 or even $8 a gallon. Those levels are a certain possibility should Congress pass
cap-and-trade legislation, which could face a vote in early June. Oil is trading at record levels, in
excess of $120 a barrel. Leading Republican Sens. James Inhofe (Okla.) and Jeff Sessions (Ala.) both
told the Business & Media Institute (BMI) energy prices would drastically increase if the Lieberman-Warner
Climate Security Act (S. 2191) is signed into law.
Price
of petrol to stay high for 8 years. As oil prices reached an all-time high, experts forecast the
cost of petrol could hit an average of £1.21 per litre within months. Over the next two years it
could even climb as high as £1.46, they said. Petrol currently costs an average of £1.13 per
litre following a month of almost daily price rises.
Gasoline May Soon Cost a Sawbuck. Get ready for
another economic shock of major proportions — a virtual doubling of prices at the gas pump to as much
as $10 a gallon. That's the message from a couple of analytical energy industry trackers, both of whom,
based on the surging oil prices, see considerably more pain at the pump than most drivers realize.
$4 a gallon could seem cheap, analysts say.
If oil reaches $200 a barrel as some analysts have said it could, forget $4-per-gallon gasoline. Think $6.64,
according to a Rice University analysis of the link between prices of crude and gasoline.
Petrol-buying panic in Britain.
British motorists are in a petrol-buying panic after a North Sea pipeline that supplies 40 percent of the
country's oil and gas was shut down because of a strike at a major refinery. ... The pipeline takes more than
700,000 barrels of crude oil ashore every day and supplies Britain and international markets.
Gas
crisis? Think back about 35 years. Amid the $4-a-gallon mutterings — and, hey, I'm not
thrilled about gas prices either — some perspective, please. This is nothing compared to the
gas crisis nearly 35 years ago.
Gas Prices —
Dems are getting exactly what they fought for. The world knows that with the power structure in
Congress that's been in place since long before the Democrats took over the majority, the Dem will fight against
and, in fact, will not allow 1) any more domestic oil production; 2) any more domestic refining capacity;
and 3) the further development of any existing technology, such as nuclear, that could have an immediate and
significant impact on our domestic energy production. Couple that with domestic policy thrusts that are
designed to increase the price of gasoline at the pump... you get the picture.
Bush faults Democrats for
gas prices. President Bush yesterday characterized Capitol Hill Democrats as hypocrites for demanding that
Saudi Arabia pump more oil while blocking attempts to increase domestic drilling in such places as Alaska and the Gulf of
Mexico.
As
Gas Prices Rose, Democrats Ignored Opportunities to Help Production. Gasoline today at the pump is
$1.25 more, on average, than it was when the Democrats took over Congress. Why is that a good place to measure?
Because during that period, we've had an opportunity to build more refineries, and the Democratic majority voted
it down. We've had an opportunity to open up additional parts of the Outer Continental Shelf and the Democratic
majority voted it down. It's clear that on the production side of the equation, this new majority is not
interested in doing anything.
Like Your $5 Gas?
When it comes to crippling, racist, and economically debilitating energy policy liberals have truly paralyzed America.
And they seem proud of their efforts. In the left's refusal to allow us to seek new energy sources they are stunting a
nation's economy, they are hurting the average family, and they are starving hungry children.
They also express
abject resentment towards anyone who dares to mention the obvious — that it is their policies that put us
in this mess to begin with and disallows our escape from it.
Democrats Solve Oil
Crisis! Democrats have been in charge of the House of Representatives for more than two years
now, and the price of gas is a whopping $1.61 higher than it was when they took control of the House and
Senate — a 58 percent increase! What was their plan in 2006? It was to empower the
Federal Trade Commission and Department of Justice to investigate and prosecute oil companies engaged in price
gouging and market manipulation. How would they prove this? By doing what they do best:
Govern by subpoena.
Democrats Fumble Ball On
Energy. [Nancy Pelosi] and congressional Democrats have pursued energy "price-gougers," even
though more than 17 studies have shown the practice is virtually nonexistent; they've punished "Big Oil"
with higher taxes, while handing subsidies to alternative energy; and they've sought to punish "market
manipulators." None of these ideas work.
The Drill-Nothing Congress.
The average price for regular gas hit $4 a gallon over the weekend. Gas prices have risen 75% since
Nancy Pelosi took over. Where's the energy independence Democrats promised two years ago?
Voters Say "Drill".
Public worry number one is now oil, jobs, and the economy, with the inflationary woes of the U.S. dollar right
underneath. The candidate who can connect with these issues will win in November. But so far neither
Obama nor McCain are dealing with the new political reality. In fact, it's all about oil right now. The
price has doubled over the past year while the economy has slumped.
Why So High? One major reason for this
overall rise in prices is because the dollar does not buy as much as it used to. And the reason the
dollar does not buy as much as it used to is because the Federal Reserve System (along with the U.S. Treasury
Department) is inundating our economy with newly created dollars. Their intent is to finance the
federal government's massive expenditures as well as to prevent a deepening recession.
Pump price
vapors: Regulation of gasoline prices doesn't work, and, by and large, our politicians know it
doesn't work. There's no escaping those remorseless facts. Why worry at this point about regulation
of energy? The numbers on the gasoline pump tell us. Anything above $3 a gallon is bad news, unless
we adjust our expectations or start riding bicycles. Then, memories of past government interventions —
the price controls of the '70s and the lines that ensued at the gasoline pump, the "windfall profits" tax on oil
profits — make chillier the sensations moving up and down the spine. Regulation isn't
equivalent to "solution" of anything.
Gas prices and $100 oil. This week,
a barrel of oil closed near $100, but why are gas prices still the same as when oil was $75 per barrel?
The refiners say gas prices are two-thirds controlled by the crude price. If that held true from one gas
price to another, gas should be at $4 right now. Well it's not that expensive, but gas is headed higher
in a time when it should be slumping.
Gasoline
prices hit new high. U.S. average retail gasoline prices have reached a new high of almost $3.20 per gallon
and will likely jump another 20 to 30 cents in the next month, worsening the pain of consumers struggling to make
ends meet in an economic downturn. Gasoline prices are rising sharply as refiners, who have kept prices down in order
to compete for sales, become more willing to pass on their higher costs of crude oil, according to an industry analyst on
Sunday [3/9/2008].
$4-a-gallon gas
forecast in some areas. Gasoline prices in the coming months are likely to top $4 a gallon in
some parts of the country, and perhaps nationally, the government said Tuesday. According to the monthly
report of the Energy Information Administration, the non-partisan statistical arm of the U.S. Energy Department,
the monthly nationwide average gasoline price is likely to peak at $3.48 a gallon in May and June.
How
Close Is $4-Per-Gallon Gasoline? Would the price of crude oil have to rocket up $40 more per
barrel for us to see $4-per-gallon gasoline? If you use the back-of-the-envelope calculation that the
government's chief energy forecaster employed Monday [11/12/2007] to gauge how much more pain at the pump is
headed our way, it would indeed take nearly $140-per-barrel crude oil to add a dollar to the pump price.
But we may not have to wait that long.
Gasoline at $4 Coming
to a Pump Near You. Whether it's $50 to fill up your Prius or $130 for the Ford Expedition,
$4-a-gallon gasoline is coming to a pump near you. Fuel prices are rising at a pace not seen since
Hurricanes Katrina and Rita knocked out a third of the U.S. oil refining industry in 2005.
Oil hits a high; some in U.S. see
$4 gas by spring. Gasoline prices, which for months lagged the big run-up in the price of oil,
are suddenly rising quickly, with some experts fearing they could hit $4 a gallon by spring. Diesel is
hitting new records daily and oil closed at an all-time high on Tuesday of $100.88 a barrel.
Or maybe not...
Gasoline
could drop 50 cents/gallon by spring. U.S. drivers could enjoy a drop of up to 50 cents per
gallon in gasoline prices by this spring as high fuel prices and the threat of a recession force them to
conserve, experts said on Wednesday [2/6/2008]. U.S. gasoline supplies hit a near-14-year high of
227.5 million barrels last week, helped by falling demand for the fuel, the U.S. Energy Information
Administration said on Wednesday.
Or maybe so...
Price at
the pump likely to reach $4. Gasoline prices could break the $4 barrier in some places this
summer despite falling demand in the United States, the world's largest oil consumer, the government's energy
forecasting agency said yesterday [4/8/2008]. Diesel prices already have soared past $4 a gallon, and
prices for regular gas are verging on $4 in high-cost states like California.
Michigan Congressman Wants 50-Cent Tax Hike on
Every Gallon of Gas. A Michigan congressman wants to put a 50-cent tax on every gallon of
gasoline to try to cut back on Americans' consumption.
Rep. John Dingell, D-Mich., wants to help cut
consumption with a gas tax but some don't agree with the idea, according to a new poll by the National Center
for Public Policy Research.
The Editor says...
Apparently the congressman doesn't understand the concept of supply and demand.
The high price of gasoline will reduce consumption without government intervention.
He's just looking for an excuse to raise taxes, and a way to make the US economy look worse than
it really is during an election year.
Oil investors welcome high
prices at pump. Regular gasoline prices vaulted to a once unthinkable record of $3.42 a gallon
yesterday [4/17/2008], paining most Americans but pleasing a growing contingent of investors who are profiting
from the fast-rising price of fuel. Scott Lee, a small investor from Georgia who owns oil company stock,
said it's the reason he is not bothered by rising pump prices.
The Wacky World of Oil: Throughout
the USA, the number of gasoline stations has been systematically cut in half since the 80's. This cuts
supply outlets and reduces retail outlet competition. In California and elsewhere, states now require
gasoline stations over a certain age to dig up and replace their worn out underground storage tanks and clean
up these alleged "hazard pollution site" — whether they are leaking or not. Independent,
privately-owned gasoline stations can't afford the hundreds of thousands of dollars to comply, so they often
close down.
Bicyclists, transit officials and
environmentalists are happy about high gas prices. The $3 gas prices posted at the station he
passes on the way to work give Kevin Ishaug 20 miles to gloat over how much he saves commuting by bike.
Ishaug, owner of the Freewheel Bike shop in Minneapolis, is one of those people who welcome higher prices at the
pump. It brings more people into his shop for new bikes or repairs, as they switch to muscle-powered
transportation to save money.
Refusal to drill impacts gas prices.
You no doubt have noticed all of the headlines concerning the recent escalation in the price of oil.
While
these headlines caught your eye, there was another one that probably didn't: "SF County Approves Drilling
Moratorium." With a unanimous vote the Santa Fe County Commission, with the governor's full support,
laid down a moratorium of at least one year on the granting of any drilling permits in the Galisteo Basin.
The 100 people in attendance stood and cheered the Commission's decision.
RV sales up despite high gas prices.
Americans are defying high gas prices and jumping into gas guzzling recreational vehicles for their summer
vacations.
Sales of RVs have shot up 22% in the past three calendar years.
The Editor says...
I suspect the popularity of RV's is partly because of
the inconvenience, delays
and invasive searches people routinely
encounter at the airports.
Energy
Bill Won't Bring Gas Price Breaks for '08. Despite claims that the newly passed energy bill
will reduce the amount that consumers pay at the pump, recent government projections show the cost of
energy rising over the next year in the United States. The president signed the energy bill in late
December. The week before the bill was signed into law, the Energy Information Administration at the
Department of Energy estimated that the cost of gasoline would average well over $3 per gallon in 2008,
with gasoline prices peaking at over $3.40 per gallon this spring.
Big Gas Price Hike Likely
Come Springtime. Experts are predicting pump prices, which jumped by almost a dollar a gallon
in each of the last two springs in many parts of the United States, will spike again this year as refiners
and gas stations switch from winter- to summer-blended fuels.
Gas whine is a sure
sign. Funny isn't it that charges of price fixing are never levelled at gas retailers when prices
go down all at once? A report released yesterday by the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives called,
Gas price gouge: The sequel, claims that Canadians have been ripped off at the pump ever since Hurricane
Katrina wreaked havoc with refineries in the fall of 2005.
Canadian drivers should expect record gas
prices. Canadian drivers should brace themselves for record gasoline prices this spring if crude
oil stays in the $90-a-barrel range, experts say. "They could be getting into the $1.30, $1.40, maybe even
the $1.50 range per litre," said Jason Toews, one of the founders of GasBuddy.com, a website designed to help
motorists find the best deals at the pump.
CNN's Wastler Backs $1 Gas Tax
Hike. Gas prices are high, but CNN wants them higher. Lots higher. CNN's Allen Wastler
told viewers April 28 that the government should increase the price with a huge new tax. "Put in a
tax to make it $4 a gallon right now," he urged.
Gas prices:
How high? Could Americans actually see a $4 price tag on a gallon of gasoline? There are
analysts out there that would argue yes — in fact, they're saying it could happen as soon as this
summer. … [Glen] Schuler says uncertainty is the culprit — uncertainty of the Gulf of Mexico
hurricane season, in Iran, Nigeria and in oil-producing countries in general. That is pushing the price
of oil higher, which in turn makes gas more expensive at the pump.
Michigan's gas prices
among highest in the country. On the eve of a proposed nationwide protest, Michigan gas prices
reached $3.27 a gallon, their highest levels ever, making the state's gas the third most expensive in the
country. Since Jan. 22, Michigan consumers have seen pump prices shoot up a total of $1.31. In
addition, Michiganders are now paying 20 cents more than the national average, as industry observers
continue to blame refinery outages and capacity issues for the sharp increase in costs.
Iranians lose access to unlimited
cheap fuel. Iran's parliament this week set May 22 as the day when the country's
15 million motorists lose access to unlimited cheap fuel. Pump prices, frozen for three years
at 80 tomans (or 9 cents) a litre, have boosted consumption far beyond the capacity of Iran's oil
refineries and meant that 40 percent of petrol has had to be imported.
Econ 101: How to Reduce
Gas Consumption. In 1931 Harold Hotelling published a paper, "The Economics of Exhaustible
Resources," that showed that the market process efficiently allocates the exploitation of a non-renewable
resource over time. His basic point is that as the supply of a resource shrinks, the price begins to
rise. That leads to an effect on the demand side. As the price of oil rises, people will use
less oil.
Fill 'er up,
Cheyenne. In a turnaround from last fall, gasoline prices in Cheyenne now rank among the lowest
of all the state capitals in the nation. Back then, the price of gas here stubbornly remained higher than
in neighboring states that have a history of charging more for a gallon of regular unleaded. On Monday
[1/8/2007], when the twice-monthly Lundberg Survey of gasoline prices was released, Cheyenne topped the list
of low prices at $2.09 a gallon.
Greens all talk, no action on
global-warming cuts. A survey by Deloitte & Touche in the summer found virtually no change
in consumer energy use and driving habits despite grumbling about skyrocketing heating and electric bills and
gasoline prices that twice reached more than $3 a gallon since 2005. Americans also have been
slow to spend more to buy more fuel-efficient cars and appliances and make their homes more energy efficient.
Soaring
gas prices drive scooter sales skyward. Record gasoline prices are fueling a boom in sales of
fuel-efficient scooters across the United States, as commuters ditch their gas-guzzlers and don helmets and
goggles to beat high prices at the pump.
If you own a yacht or a limo or an airplane I do not feel sorry for you.
High fuel prices keep
boaters closer to harbor. Bill Bouwens relaxed on his 36-foot express cruiser this week in Waukegan Harbor,
where his boat will stay docked a lot more often this summer. That's the sacrifice Bouwens says he'll make because
filling up his 300-gallon tank costs a whopping $1,300 or more.
With
RVs, the road's less traveled. Bill and Barbara Wright sold their house in Georgia two years ago and drove
off in their RV with plans to visit 50 states in five years. But record fuel prices have forced them to cut
their annual mileage in half, add at least a year to the schedule, and give up their dream of driving to Alaska.
Driving less? It's costing the state. High
gas and parking prices are convincing people to drive less. Statewide, traffic volumes are down by two
percent.
The high price of gas is the real problem. It's got most of us trying to figure out where we
can cut back. But every time you save a gallon, it costs the state 36 cents.
Funds for Highways
Plummet As Drivers Cut Gasoline Use. An unprecedented cutback in driving is slashing the funds
available to rebuild the nation's aging highway system and expand mass-transit options, underscoring the
economic impact of high gasoline prices. The resulting financial strain is touching off a political
battle over government priorities in a new era of expensive oil.
Oklahoma's painful car
culture: For many people in Oklahoma, life is built around the car. With several refineries in the
region, years of cheap fuel have made it possible for many people to live far from their jobs. Now the situation is
unraveling.
Gasoline at $6 vs warming? It's
hard to say which is scarier — apocalyptic global warming scenarios or the economic impact of some of
the proposals designed to prevent them. A recent European Environment Agency (EEA) study reported
greenhouse-gas emissions from motor vehicles continue rising due to increased driving, despite heavy
fuel taxes that boost prices there above $6 per gallon. Even with gas prices more than twofold
that in the U.S., Europe falls short of its global-warming goals.
You Can't Fuel All of the People All of the Time.
Environmentalists are constantly clamoring for higher gas taxes as the cure-all to their insane global warming
theory. Clinton proposed a 26-cent tax on gas. John Kerry said it should be 50 cents. Gore
endorsed the Malthusian proposal of Paul and Anne Ehrlich in "The Population Explosion" that gas taxes be
raised gradually to match prices in Europe and Japan. The result is consumers now pay about 46 cents
per gallon in gasoline taxes.
The Return of the 55 MPH Speed Limit
Trucking industry proposes limiting
speed to save fuel. Struggling with record diesel prices, the trucking industry's main trade group yesterday [5/8/2008]
introduced a plan to reduce fuel consumption and emissions over the next decade mainly by having its members slow down.
The American Trucking Associations [wants to] limit the speed new trucks can travel to no more than 68 mph and reduce
the national speed limit to 65 mph for all vehicles.
The Editor says...
Get a clue. That idea has already been tried, and it flopped. Richard Nixon implemented
a 55 mph national speed limit, which was nothing but an annoyance, although it provided a big boost
to the electronics industry. There was a surge in the sales of CB radios, radar detectors and
more advanced radar guns. The so-called Criminal Band was expanded from 23 to
40 channels, even though 90% of the activity was on Channel 19.
Is 55 in Our Future?
If there's one thing that's worse than paying $4 per gallon for gasoline, it's the resurgent talk of lowering
speed limits to conserve fuel. Because, of course, these lowered limits won't be enforced as a "conservation"
measure. Any curtailment of speed limits will be treated as a saaaaafety issue — just
as happened during the Dark Decades of the 55 mph National Maximum Speed Limit. "Speeding" tickets
will be issued and "points" assigned. At the stroke of a lawmaker's pen (and the cop's, too) driving
"x" MPH will suddenly become "unsafe," rather than merely wasteful. This is the most intolerable
aspect of the whole scam.
Higher gas prices not slowing drivers.
Even in a time of $4-a-gallon gas, the slow lane is lonely these days. For all the griping about gas
prices, there's no clamor for the return of the 55 mph speed limit of the '70s and '80s —
though most agree it reduces consumption and saves money.
Return of the 55-Miles-Per-Hour Speed Limit?
Republican Senator John Warner of Virgina has asked Energy Secretary Samuel Bodman to calculate what speed would provide
optimum gasoline efficiency under current technology. In a letter to Bodman, Warner cited studies that show
the 55-mile per hour national speed limit saved 167-thousand barrels of oil a day — after it was imposed by
Congress in 1974 because of the Arab oil embargo. That speed limit was repealed in 1995.
The Editor says...
The "optimum" speed is different for cars and trucks. Why not also impose a speed limit
on locomotives and buses and cargo ships?
The
Insanity of Drive-55 Laws. It didn't seem possible that politicians could think up a sillier
energy proposal than Barack Obama's windfall profits tax on oil companies, but Republican Sen. John Warner
of Virginia has done just that. Earlier this month, Mr. Warner suggested a return to the federal
55-mile-per-hour speed limit on America's highways, as a way to save on national gasoline consumption.
Campaign
For 55 MPH Speed Limit Renewed. Nearly 15 years after it was removed by Congress, the effort
to limit driving speed in the United States to 55 mph is back. The national 55-miles-per-hour speed
limit was introduced in 1970s. Proposed by President Nixon and enacted in January 1974, the nationwide
speed limit was supposed to be a temporary emergency response to oil shortages and was to expire in mid-1975,
but Congress quickly made it permanent.
The Federal Price Gouging Protection Act
Who Is Gouging Whom? The real gouger
driving up gasoline prices is not the private sector, it is our government. To "gouge" means to extort,
to take by force — something that oil companies and gas stations have no power to do.
Gasoline Price Gouging Laws Will
Not Benefit Consumers. Sometimes the simplest solution is the best one, but not in the case of
high gasoline prices. Previous federal efforts to simply outlaw high prices through gasoline price
controls have a bad track record, actually hurting consumers rather than helping them.
The
Coffee Talk on Gas Prices That Isn't: To highlight their empathy before a
frustrated public, Democrats and Republicans alike in the U.S. House of Representatives
passed the Federal Price Gouging Protection Act. According to a study recently issued
by American Council for Capital Formation (ACCF), the likely impact of this legislation and
others like it is the imposition of price controls on gasoline similar to those in the 1970s
which caused major supply disruptions, rationing and endless waiting lines for gasoline.
History is set to soon repeat itself if these bills become law.
Pumping
Politics: So if history shows that proposed anti-price-gouging legislation has fallen flat on its face,
and if two federal agencies have said they haven't found any evidence of price gouging by oil and natural gas companies,
and no one has been prosecuted under existing laws for price fixing, then why the new legislation?
Congress Should Not Criminalize
"Price Gouging" of Gasoline. Congressional demagoguery over prices at the pump has reached new
heights in the "Federal Energy Price Protection Act of 2006" (H.R. 5253). Though the conduct at
issue, "price gouging," goes undefined in the legislation, it (whatever it is) could be punished with
civil and criminal sanctions that include a $150,000,000 fine and imprisonment for up to two years. In
addition to being economically harmful, the criminal provisions of H.R. 5253 are potentially
unconstitutional and certainly immoral.
What to Do About High Gasoline Prices: In
response to recent rises in gas prices, we are once again hearing calls for the government to "do something" to
force prices lower. But no matter what the price of gasoline is, such calls are wrong. All market
fluctuations in the price of gasoline, up or down, are a good thing — and none of the government's business.
Who Is "Gouging" Whom?
Last Wednesday, 79 members of the House of Representatives introduced a bill instituting criminal and civil
penalties on any corporation or individual found guilty of gasoline "price gouging." But the real gouger
driving up gasoline prices is not the private sector, it is our government … which has engaged — with
popular support — in the gouging of both the producers and consumers of gasoline.
'Price gouging':
One lawmaker has a plan. Even though she admits the "problem" has not arisen in Nevada in recent
memory, state Sen. Dina Titus, D-Las Vegas, now offers Senate Bill 82, which seeks to ban "price gouging"
by classifying as an illegal "deceptive trade practice" the sale of a consumer good or service "for an
unconscionable price before or during a state of emergency."
The Gouge Party:
America was saved Tuesday from a Democratic Congress determined to do more damage to our economy and
raise oil prices still higher. Energy taxes and eco-extremism make Democrats the real oil gougers.
Requiem for a heavyweight?
The fate of the Hummer brand is up in the air. GM, which bought the brand from military contractor AM General in 1998,
has plowed a load of capital into Hummer, including $250 million for a plant expansion in Shreveport, La. It has
a pickup truck version of the mid-size H3, the H3T, in the pipeline for a summer release. Meanwhile, product
development is well along on a Jeep Wrangler-size 4x4 called the H4.
Hummer, How We Need
Thee. No set of wheels since the hapless Edsel has been as persistently reviled as the Hummer. [But]
America needs the Hummer to remind us of what has always made our automobiles stand out, from the tailfin 1950s to the
muscle car 1960s and '70s: swagger. Americans don't just drive their cars — they proclaim something about
themselves by driving them.
Car rental
companies caught short as demand for smaller vehicles soars. David Sikorski went to a Hertz in
Austin, Texas, last month to rent a car for a business trip to Dallas. He'd booked a fuel-efficient
mid-size sedan, hoping to keep expenses down on the 400-mile round trip. What he got was a
16-mile-per-gallon Ford Explorer sport utility vehicle. "I walked right back in and asked for something
smaller," said the Austin computer data specialist, who eventually was given a Hyundai. "They claimed it
was an upgrade, but I sure don't want an upgrade if it means driving an SUV."
Soccer-mom stigma helping to slow down
minivan sales. Asked recently how the U.S. minivan market has been faring, Nissan Motor Co.'s Dominique
Thormann had a concise answer. "It collapsed," said Thormann, a senior vice president of Nissan North America.
While the rapid sales decline of pickup and sport utility vehicles has been grabbing the headlines, minivan sales have also
taken a tumble, falling 20% during the first five months of this year.
"Supply and demand" at work:
Gas-hog
owners can't sell them. Tammy Fontanilla loves her red 2004 Dodge Ram pickup truck, but when
gas prices began to soar last year, she felt she had no choice but to put it up for sale. Problem is,
there's little demand for a vehicle that gets 13 miles per gallon and costs nearly $100 to
fill up.
Natural-gas stations fall behind.
Drivers of vehicles that run on natural gas have escaped prices above $4 per gallon for gasoline, but they're
having to wait longer, or search harder, to fuel up along the Wasatch Front. Many drivers of natural-gas
vehicles say they have gone to filling stations in recent weeks only to find that increased demand has
created insufficient pressure in the station's tank to pump the fuel.
Priceless politics, Part II: What
do prices do? Prices impose the most effective kind of rationing — self-rationing. Why is rationing
necessary? Because what everybody wants always adds up to more than there is. It doesn't matter
whether you are talking about a capitalist economy, a socialist economy, a feudal economy or whatever.
Resources are limited but desires are not. That is the basic and defining problem of economics.
Wal-Mart
sales may reflect gas costs. While retailers that attract higher-income consumers continued to
do well in November, others, especially Wal-Mart, may still be feeling the pinch of high fuel prices.
Wal-Mart's November sales were down 1%, and the company predicted December sales would be flat or up
just 1%.
Big Oil's New Conspiracy: We have
heard much in recent months about the plot by oil companies to gouge consumers at the pump. Now, I am
writing to report another insidious plot on the part of Big Oil. They are scheming to lower prices.
Shocking, I know. But it is all true.
CNN talking head's conspiracy
theory runs out of gas. When gas prices shot up in spring, some in the media were quick to
criticize "corporate greed," but as prices plummet, even that decline has to be a "conspiracy."
Enron and Today's Oil and Gas
Prices. If a Senate study concluded that legislation signed by George W. Bush and supported
by Halliburton was partially responsible for today's high oil and gas prices, do you think you would have heard
about it? Well, such a report was released by the Senate. However, the president that signed the
law in question was William Jefferson Clinton, and the company that strongly lobbied for its passage was
Enron. Yet, mysteriously, this study was almost completely ignored.
Pain at the Pump: Gas Prices Rise on
Democrats' Watch. Well, remember that? The Democrats blaming the president for high gas
prices, pledging to do something about it if they took control of Congress. Well, since Election Day,
the price of a gallon of gas has jumped nearly 40 percent.
Gas tax trial
balloon. A 2004 Congressional Budget Office paper concluded that if CAF standards were raised by
3.8 miles per gallon, it would take 15 years for gasoline consumption to fall by just 10 percent,
and the economic cost would be high. Raising the gas tax by 46 cents would also cut fuel consumption
by 10 percent, but do so much more promptly.
More about Corporate Average Fuel Economy standards can be found here.
Paying at the Pump: Gasoline
Taxes in America. Early gasoline taxes in the states were explicitly created in an attempt
to charge road users for the privilege of using roads. However, from the very inception of
gasoline taxation, public officials have faced temptation to divert gasoline tax revenue to projects that
are only tangentially related to transportation and that are often purely politically motivated.
Hawaiian gas prices dip under $3.
While still the highest in the nation, Hawaii's statewide average for gasoline has dipped below $3 a gallon for
the first time in six months. Yesterday's average for regular, self-serve unleaded
was $2.98 a gallon, according to AAA's Fuel Gauge Report. Next highest were Alaska at $2.76 and
Washington state at $2.57.
7-Eleven
Drops Citgo as Supplier. 7-Eleven Inc. dropped Venezuela-owned Citgo as its gasoline supplier
after more than 20 years as part of a previously announced plan by the convenience store operator to
launch its own brand of fuel. 7-Eleven officials said Wednesday [9/27/2006] that the decision was
partly motivated by politics.
7-Eleven Dropping Venezuela-Backed
Citgo. Convenience store operator 7-Eleven Inc. is dropping Venezuela-backed Citgo as its
gasoline supplier at more than 2,100 locations and switching to its own brand of fuel.
The Editor says...
Petro Express is owned by the same people as Citgo,
according to various sources [1]
[2]
[3]
[4].
I first heard of the connection from the RF Cafe.
The
Russians are coming… with another Lukoil gas station. The gas station down at the corner
is taking on a bold new look. The latest player on the block is Lukoil, a Russian oil company that
holds the second largest oil reserves in the world behind only ExxonMobil. In the past 16 months,
Lukoil has been rapidly converting hundreds of Mobil service stations in the region to its own distinctive
brand.
Terror Free Oil: The gas station at
131 Street and Q used to show a Sinclair dinosaur. Now, in big bold letters "Terror Free Oil."
The idea is to sell gasoline made from oil orginating in countries friendly to the United States. On its
website, the terror free oil organization says the U.S. is funding its own demise.
Conspiracy
theories run out of gas when drivers fill their tanks. When gasoline prices topped $3 a gallon
in mid-summer, motorists were justifiably aggravated about the high price. So now that gasoline has
plunged below $2 a gallon you would think everybody would be happier.
State-by-State
Motor Fuel Taxes. Here are the latest state motor fuel tax rates effective 7/1/06. … This
comprehensive summary looks at both gasoline and diesel tax rates. Bar charts illustrating the state
taxes are included. [PDF]
Decline
in Gas Prices Isn't Buoying Detroit. Just when $3-a-gallon gasoline looked as if it were here to
stay, it left. But it was around long enough to devastate Detroit's automakers by convincing many car
shoppers that smaller is better.
This logic only makes sense if you're an environmentalist.
Could Lower Gas Prices Be
Bad?. From the way some people are carrying on, you would think it was the sky that was falling,
not gas prices. Heading up the field is Daniel Akst, whose op-ed piece in The New York Times today lays
out the case for the negative effects of lowering gas prices. "Anything that reinforces the role of
fossil fuels — particularly oil — as the world's primary energy source, is bad, not
good," Akst writes. … "Lower oil prices would promote more driving," Akst notes.
Has Citgo become
a political tool for Hugo Chávez? One of the USA's largest refiners, Citgo is a subsidiary
of Venezuela's state-owned oil company, Petroleos de Venezuela S.A. (PDVSA). As such, it ultimately
belongs to Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez, an avowedly anti-American leader who counts Fidel Castro
among his closest friends and mocks President Bush as a "genocidal murderer."
Katrina and the punch at the
pump: Lost amid the anniversary articles about Hurricane Katrina is how we've dealt with the
energy fallout. We've had a year to get used to $3-per-gallon gasoline and to come to grips with the
vulnerability of our energy supplies. What have we learned? We've learned that the impact
didn't have to be so bad and that Washington can take measures to ensure that the next big storm won't
hurt drivers and homeowners as badly.
High Gas Prices Courtesy of Environmental
Rhetoric. As a matter of national security and as a significant boost to the American economy,
it makes no sense to not assure and achieve a higher level of energy independence. So why, in mid-May,
did the House of Representatives reject an end to the quarter-century ban on oil and natural gas drilling in
85 percent of America's coastal waters?
An Energy Lesson from Cuba and China. An
unlikely political figure is willing to fight for lower gas prices. His name: Fidel Castro.
He's working with foreign investors, including China, to find oil off the Cuban coast, close to American
waters. In contrast, American companies aren't looking for oil off the Florida coast, because it's part
of the 85 percent of the nation's offshore areas where drilling's not allowed.
House Roll Call Vote on
Offshore Drilling. The 232-187 roll call Thursday [6/29/2006] by which the House voted to
end the offshore drilling ban.
Cuba oil probe spurs calls
for U.S. drilling. Congressional proponents of oil and gas drilling are pointing to
Cuba's exploration off the coast of Florida — with help from China — as a prime
reason to open up U.S. drilling in the eastern Gulf of Mexico.
FTC
chief sees a gas-price-gouging law passing. The head of the U.S. Federal Trade Commission said on
Thursday [11/16/2006] that Congress will probably pass a law designed to stop gasoline price-gouging after it
convenes in January, despite objections from the agency.
Who is "gouging" whom at the pumps? [Rising oil
and gas prices] is an issue that affects many Americans and Democrats hope to convince those Americans that
greedy Bush oil buddies are to blame. But as usual, the real facts are quite different from the bogus
campaign rhetoric … Who is getting rich at the gas pumps? For starters, many average Americans
who hold stock in the oil companies, either directly or indirectly through their 410k or mutual fund. But
the fact is, the gross profit margin for a gallon of gas in America today, is what it has always been, on
average, .08 cents per gallon.
The Big Three Pump Up While Drivers Pay
Out. Detroit is pushing hot wheels this summer, figuring Americans want to play NASCAR driver
in new versions of vintage muscle cars. But a let's-burn-rubber message seems likely to stall in an
era of $3-a-gallon-gas and more fuel-efficient foreign brands.
Some relief appearing at the
pump. Are gasoline prices, after hovering just below $2.90 a gallon for weeks,
actually on their way down?
Big Media are Repeatedly Wrong Claiming
'Record-High' Gas Prices. Since Hurricane Katrina swept ashore on the Gulf Coast, we've heard
seemingly countless reports of "record high" gas or oil prices. From the beginning of September last
year, the big three networks — ABC, CBS and NBC — have told us about record high gas
or oil prices close to 100 times. They've been wrong each and every time.
Claim of Record High Gas Prices Tanks Under
Scrutiny. Don't believe the media hype: Prices at the pump aren't as bad as you've been
lead to believe. Compared to what they were nearly 25 years ago, today's gas prices are a
bargain. And they're a bargain compared to other necessities, too. According to Bureau of
Labor Statistics, the average cost of a gallon of regular unleaded gasoline in U.S. cities was $1.41 in
April 1981. Excluding federal and state gas taxes, this meant the price was around $1.26. In
today's dollars, that would be about $2.83 per gallon. But in May, the before-tax cost of a gallon of
unleaded gasoline was just $2.29 — about 19 percent lower than that.
Governmental Viscosity
Breakdown: Members of Congress, such as Pennsylvania's Arlen Specter, who … manages to
exude split-atom energy when it comes to cheerleading for bad ideas, are calling for a windfall profits
tax on the oil companies. Of course, the tax would be passed on to consumers, but Congress will deal
with that later — it'll be good fodder for calling for the federalization of the oil
industry. In a Beltway culture that confuses motion with action, windfall profits
taxes are but flailing victims in the quicksand of lunacy.
Higher Gas
Prices Require Higher Minimum Wage, Dems Say. Before leaving Washington, D.C., for the Memorial
Day recess, Democrats in the U.S. Congress Thursday [5/25/2006] criticized Republicans for failing to "lower
skyrocketing gas prices" and called for the GOP to show "real leadership" by raising the minimum wage.
Did
someone mention the Minimum Wage?
Consumer mood rises on
lower gas prices. U.S. consumers were more optimistic in June as once-soaring gasoline
prices eased, and the government reported that a key measure of the nation's trade deficit narrowed
more than expected in the first quarter. The University of Michigan's preliminary June index
of consumer sentiment read 82.4, up from May's final reading of 79.1 and above Wall Street expectations
for a reading of 79.0.
'Green' Politicians Add to Gas Price
Woes. Certainly increased demand for oil from the growing Chinese and Indian economies and
instability in the Middle East are major pressures on oil prices, but both Republicans and Democrats have
added to these pressures by allowing the environmental movement to tie our energy policy in knots.
Reporting
on the economy is worse than the economy. The same people who blame Bush for higher gas prices
resist allowing the president to do the things he can. This includes a suspension or reduction of taxes,
permission to drill in Arctic National Wildlife Refuge and the outer continental shelf, and allowance for the
construction of nuclear power plants.
No Way to Handle a Fuel
Crisis. There is no big oil "collusion;" the crude oil price is universal. It was
54.8 percent of the cost of a gallon of gasoline in March and rising in response to supply concerns
amid geopolitical tensions in oil-producing countries. Federal and state taxes account for about
24 percent of the price.
We are all Marxists
now. National Public Radio's Juan Williams, appearing on Fox News Sunday, insisted repeatedly
that "supply is at an eight year high" as proof that the oil companies are cheating us. He kept
repeating the phrase, as if that would make it a more sensible statement. It didn't. … Frustrated
by his inability to convince others of his nonsense, Williams then insisted that there is no connection
between supply and demand.
Pumping Gas: The facts are
not pretty. Gas prices at the pump are not going to drop significantly in the foreseeable future, no
matter what Congress or federal and state governments do. Sure, they can lower their take on a gallon
of gas, which … is an average of 45 to 46 cents. At best that would be a temporary solution.
After all, what government would be willing to long forego a great source of tax revenue?
Incendiary
Ignorance: I'd planned on ignoring the inferno of idiocy raging in the nation's capital over
gas prices, but it's looking like an eternal flame. First came the Democrats. For more than a
decade their leading lights have extolled higher gas taxes, and hence higher gas prices, to pay for
everything from school roofs to the development of alternative energy sources that would usher in the
economic Shangri-La of "energy independence" — whatever that is.
Say It
With Me: Supply and Demand. Precisely 10 years ago (April 29, 1996) as gas prices
reached a shocking $1.27 a gallon, President Clinton ordered his Energy and Justice Departments to
launch investigations to find out why. In my column that week, I offered a wild guess
as to why: "Supply is down and demand is up."
Energy Policy for Idiots: In the
short run, the supply of gasoline is fairly inelastic. Current inventories of crude oil and refined
products are fairly difficult to adjust, so that the supply of gasoline is what it is. That is
why it is pretty certain that drivers face a "tough summer," in the words of the President. If the
supply of gasoline is what it is, then the price of gasoline will be whatever it takes to limit demand to
meet the supply. If that means $3.00 a gallon, then consumers are going to end up paying $3.00 per
gallon, no matter what the tax is on gasoline.
High gas prices
cause more hot air. The Congressional Research Service estimated in 1990 that [Jimmy] Carter's
windfall profits tax (really an excise tax) decreased domestic oil production by 3 percent to
6 percent, while pumping up dependence on foreign oil by 8 percent to 16 percent. Thank
you, Congress.
Brazilian drivers opt for
ethanol-gas mix. [In Brazil], ethanol is a sort of like a miracle drug, having helped Brazil to
kick its own dependence on foreign sources of oil by the end of last year. In the United States, Brazil's
success story is either a free-market solution the United States should try to match, or a pipe dream that is
impossible — and dangerous — to try to copy.
Which costs more, ethanol or gasoline? With
oil topping $135 a barrel, ethanol must be cheaper than gasoline, right? Not if you adjust for the
fact that ethanol has about 30% less energy content than gasoline by volume.
Mixing
gasoline and moonshine: The House approved by a vote of 389 to 34 a plan to
impose criminal penalties and fines of up to $150 million for refiners and wholesalers for
"gouging," with a fine of $2 million for retailers. It is pitiable that 389 members of
the House were so eager to make a public spectacle of their economic illiteracy. It is revealing
that they totally exempted congressional moonshine — otherwise known as ethanol.
More derogatory information about ethanol can be
found here.
Congressional squawking won't bring fuel
prices down. When a crisis strikes, Americans can count on Congress to swing into action. So
as gasoline prices soared toward $3 per gallon, lawmakers did what they do best: They complained.
Gas prices and hot
air: Political hot air will not bring down gas prices. Last week Sen. Charles Schumer
(D-NY) claimed that gas prices are rising because too many oil companies have been allowed to merge in the
last decade. If one could identify 100 factors responsible for causing high gas prices, mergers would
be number 101.
Think $2.90 for Gasoline Is High? Try
$5.17. Public hysteria over high gasoline prices is unwarranted, according to [Jerry]
Taylor. "I actually saw an MSNBC story the other day which interviewed a pawn shop owner who
said people were selling earrings and diamonds and what not to pay for gasoline. Those kinds of stories
just make me very annoyed because they are utterly unhinged and they lack a tie to reality," he said.
Government Gasoline Help? Someone
messed up all right but it was not the terrified oil executives. Congress did it with an assist from a
nervous Executive afraid to veto the bill that caused the crisis. The one thing Congress does not promise
that would actually work is for it to stop "solving" the problem.
Serious About Gas Prices. It is
disappointing that President George W. Bush has decided to make cheap political points about high gas
prices instead of promoting policies that will lead to more domestic oil production and lower prices.
Gas gouge?
ExxonMobil paid $23 billion in taxes last year, which gives us some idea of the scale of an activity
whose gross income exceeds the combined income of IBM, General Motors and AT&T.
Bush orders suspension of gas
rules. President Bush yesterday [4/25/2006] ordered a temporary suspension of environmental
rules for gasoline, which are creating bottlenecks in U.S. gasoline markets, and announced a federal
investigation into potential manipulation of gas prices that have topped $3 per gallon.
Bush on Gas Prices: Who's He
Kidding? With gasoline prices close to $3 a gallon, President Bush this morning [4/25/2006]
gave a disingenuous speech to an alternative fuels association about what he was going to do to stem the
rising tide. There were a few flashes of candor and insight, but, on the whole, it was a sad example
of political capitulation by a former Texas oilman who certainly knows better. What Bush clearly
understands is that prices rise when demand increases faster than supply, and that supply is being limited
in the United States by government.
$100 Rebate Checks
Here is another bad idea that went over like a lead balloon.
Senators to push for $100 gas
rebate checks. Most American taxpayers would get $100 rebate checks to offset the pain of
higher pump prices for gasoline, under an amendment Senate Republicans hope to bring to a vote
Thursday [4/27/2006].
The Editor says...
Let me make a prediction: Many of these checks will end up in the hands of
people who ride the bus to work and don't buy gas. (Need I remind you of last year's
FEMA debit card fiasco?) And
where do you suppose the $100 is going to come from? Your paycheck, of course.
Senate GOP backs off from oil
tax increase. Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, under pressure from business leaders, retreated
Monday [5/1/2006] from a plan that would have used a tax increase on oil companies and other businesses to
fund a $100 gasoline rebate for millions of motorists.
The $100
rebate plan is a loser. Last week Republicans announced a plan to mail a $100 rebate check to
voters to offset the rising price of gas. The plan has not gone over well with anyone.
Gas Fumes Obscure GOP Base. In
short, the Republican base wants to know: Where's all this partisan extremism we were promised? … The
actual GOP response? Hundred-dollar rebates. Cash money, friend, just for drivin'. We feel
your pain: Here, have some money we borrowed from someone else.
Stupid Petrol Tricks: Dems Feign Pity for
Consumers. The Democrats are sounding terribly concerned about the high prices we're paying for
gasoline these days. Upon closer inspection, however, we can see that they have no problem with gas prices
being higher than three dollars a gallon. In fact, they prefer it that way. Their only real
objection is about where the bulk of that money is going.
A
Self-Inflicted Energy Mess: It's always tempting to blame soaring energy costs on some
nefarious foreign plot and be done with it. … But, as we've written before, those aren't the only
things to blame. The federal government, with its balkanized gasoline requirements, its taxes
and its myriad regulations, deserves a large measure of responsibility for the soaring cost of gasoline.
It's Hard Out Here for a
Pump. I would be more interested in what the Democrats had to say about high gas prices
if these were not the same people who refused to let us drill for oil in Alaska, imposed massive
restrictions on building new refineries, and who shut down the development of nuclear power in
this country decades ago.
Price-gouging in the
public interest. Today, the U.S. must import 10 percent of its gasoline as well as 57 percent
of its oil. Thus, even the temporary closure of several refineries by Hurricane Katrina and Hurricane Rita
sharply inflated pump prices. Environmental regulations, backed by activists who mix demonstrations and
lawsuits, create delays and inflate costs. One Arizona project begun a decade ago is still at least five
years away from completion.
Oil industry helped Texas craft storm
strategy. By the time [Hurricane] Rita's 175 mph winds followed Katrina into the Gulf of
Mexico and made a beeline for Texas, motorists had tapped just about every drop of gas available in Houston
and the surrounding area. Complicating the exodus was that until Rita, no Texans had ever been told they
must evacuate from a storm area. ... Damaged production platforms and evacuated refineries left the oil
industry vulnerable to the crush in demand for gasoline.
Skip The Gas Profit
Tinkering. Though many Americans seem to feel low gasoline and oil prices are their
birthright, price controls are disingenuous and counterproductive, leading to reduced investment
in oil and gas exploration and possibly gasoline shortages — the exact opposite of what
consumers and the country need.
Of Price and Men. There
has been much talk about "price gouging" by the oil companies, as we witnessed the average
gasoline price rise to about $3.10 before falling to pre-Katrina levels most recently. But as I
listened to well-paid pundits pillory the oil industry for being slick, I was left wondering: what
is gouging?
The
consumer rip-off. Since allegations of oil company price-gouging have become
topical, let's look at real price manipulation.
How congress pumps up
prices. At the same time oil companies were blistered in Senate hearings because their
companies earned hundreds of millions of dollars in the recent quarter of 2005, the Tax Foundation's
Scott Hodge reported that in the last 25 years, oil companies paid more than $2.2 trillion
(that's right trillion) in taxes to federal and state governments. That's more than threefold
the oil companies' profits in the same period.
How Big is a Hawaiian Gallon?
Oil industry resists
adjusting gas pumps for hot climates. The Hawaiian gallon contains nearly 234 cubic inches of
fuel — about 3 cubic inches more than is dispensed in the rest of the United States. The extra
volume, required by state law, helps offset the higher temperature in this tropical climate, which causes the
gasoline to expand. If the gallon weren't temperature-adjusted, Hawaiians would receive less energy per
gallon than called for under the government standard. That's because for nearly a century, gasoline and
diesel have been measured across America as if they were being dispensed at a temperature of 60 degrees,
a more condensed gallon of 231 cubic inches.
The Editor says...
I see nothing about a Hawaiian gallon in
15 USC Chapter 6, or
in NIST Handbook 130, and I'm waiting
for a reply from the weights and measures people
at NIST. Of course, it's a lot
hotter in Texas than in Hawaii, but keep in mind that most gasoline storage tanks are underground,
where the temperature is closer to 60 degrees. Smart gasoline pumps could measure the temperature of
the fuel as it is delivered and adjust the price accordingly, but I doubt if that will ever happen.
But again, gasoline expands as it heats, which is good news for the consumer. The expansion means that
as gasoline comes out of the cold underground storage tank at the gas station, it occupies less space than
it will when it warms up in your gas tank. On a hot day, you may end up with two percent more gas (by
volume) than you paid for.
Updated 8/30/2006:
Upon further reflection, I'm starting to have my doubts about this Hawaiian Gallon story. First of all,
gasoline has a coefficient of expansion
of 0.00060/°F.*
So, if my calculations are right, gasoline expands by one percent for every sixteen degrees of
temperature increase. That's not much expansion. And in any event, if Hawaii really is so hot --
consistently hot year round -- the way to accommodate the difference is to adjust the price, not the
definition of a gallon.
Updated 6/19/2007:
When it's hot, you lose at gas pump.
Almost a century ago, the industry and regulators agreed to define a gallon of gasoline as 231 cubic inches at
60 degrees.
During the energy crisis in the 1970s, tropical Hawaii decided to set a base fuel
temperature of 80 degrees, meaning that consumers there get more bang for their buck because retailers
now dispense 234 cubic inches of gas per gallon rather than 231.
[That's only 1.3 percent.]
Basic
economics: In the wake of the spike in fuel prices, many Americans demand that politicians
do something. You can bet the rent money that whatever politicians do will end up harming
consumers.
The Left Caused Higher
Gas Prices. Because of environmania, the left has prevented domestic exploration of energy
sources such as those to be found in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge. But the fear by a myopic
but noisy few with poor science on their side that caribou would be upset or displaced by exploration, is
inhibiting the growth of our national economy and requiring us to beg for mercy from [OPEC] dictators who
have no reason to offer any.
"Fueling our
enemies' engines". In order to "feed their habit," addicts must pay out mountains of
cold hard cash to very unsavory characters who are often as deadly as the addiction itself. That's
always been the case with heroin or crack and today it's increasingly true of petroleum.
On the other hand...
We're Not Addicts!
It's a confused and confusing debate but it can be boiled down to this: On one side are those who believe
the answer is for us to slash our demand for energy. On the other side are those who believe the answer
is to greatly increase our supply.
Gas price vapors: Now
that the gasoline price has plummeted across the country, shouldn't the Senate committee that berated oil
company executives when prices were up now praise them? If the price of gas can be so easily
manipulated by the oil companies, shouldn't the senators give those corporate execs medals instead
of tongue-lashings? Fair is fair.
EPA Rules Raise Gas Prices. While
it is possible to expand domestic refinery capacity without constructing new refineries, current and planned
EPA rules act as disincentives to refinery expansion. In 1997, the EPA made air quality standards across
the country more stringent. … These standards were not based on sound science and, consequently,
aren't likely to produce benefits commensurate with their $100 billion annual cost.
Katrina Reveals Gas
Price Folly. A new oil refinery has not been built in the United States since
1976. During that time, our gasoline use has increased over 25 percent. The
nation's 149 existing refineries have been running at maximum capacity trying to meet
record demand and, as a result, not only do we import oil, we actually have to
import 10 percent of our daily gasoline from refineries overseas.
The Petro sky
is not falling. This "crisis" will push us — finally — to
tap America's significant reserves in ANWAR and offshore California and Florida. Fanatical
tree huggers' silly politics for years have blocked development of huge fields which will finally come
online during the next 10 years. … The petroleum sky is not falling. We have and
will continue to have enough energy resources. Current upward price swings have
little to do with current and projected supply.
No Easy
Answers For Post-Katrina Gas Prices. The hurricane's impact on already-high
gasoline prices is hard to ignore. Politicians are coming up with the usual list of
easy answers to ease pain at the pump, but unfortunately, they are the wrong answers. Setting
price caps, pumping lots of oil out of the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, and going after
industry "price-gouging" and collusion will not have much of an impact, and each comes
with problems of its own.
Ignoring
economics: Part II. What all this boils down to is that prices higher than what
observers are used to are called "gouging." In other words, prices under normal conditions are
supposed to prevail under abnormal conditions. This completely misunderstands the role
of prices.
Running
out of gas. Everyone knows what the problem really is. It's Economics 101:
increasing demand and precariously tight supply. Yet for three decades we have done criminally
little about it. Conservatives argued for more production, liberals argued for more conservation,
and each side blocked the other's remedies — when even a child can see that we need both.
Oil Company
Executives Defend Profits. The chiefs of five major oil companies defended
the industry's huge profits Wednesday [11/9/2005] at a Senate hearing where lawmakers said
they should explain prices and assure people they're not being gouged.
Windfall
for the dimwitted. Sen. Byron Dorgan, the North Dakota Democrat, … recently
got 34 colleagues, none of them Republicans, to vote for his measure to punish oil companies for
earning profits that, relative to revenue, were unimpressive.
High Taxes Cause High
Gas Prices. Americans everywhere have felt the impact of higher gasoline
prices during the past year. In response, our government officials have offered up
the usual "solution": greater regulation of the oil industry. Administration
officials have ordered an FTC antitrust probe, while vote-seeking politicians have condemned
the oil industry and called for an investigation into collusion and price gouging. The
truth is that costly federal taxes and regulations largely are to blame for high fuel
prices, not convenient scapegoats like OPEC and the oil companies.
High
gas prices aren't as bad as some think. Our immediate spike in gas prices was
brought on by the destruction Hurricane Katrina caused in the oil-rich Gulf of Mexico. But
even if this had not happened, and even if there were not a war in Iraq, the price of gas was bound
to rise. China and other highly populated countries are developing rapidly and will
demand gas as they join the "I love my car" club.
Feds' Gas Tax Has Lived Too Long. The federal
gas tax was levied back in 1956 with the promise of finishing the interstate highway system. Well, that
system was completed by 1982. To no one's surprise, the tax didn't stop then.
Overtaxed at the Pump: What's
Behind the High Gas Prices. Federal and state taxes make up the largest component of the retail
price of gasoline beyond the cost of a barrel of crude oil. Taxes can add between 26 cents and
53 cents to the retail cost of a gallon of gas. The total annual gasoline tax bill for motorists is
$53 billion per year.
The Burden of Hidden Taxes: When you
buy a gallon of gasoline, the government receives the largest chunk of your money. According to one
report, for a dollar's worth of gasoline, 34 cents are accounted for by exploration and production,
refining takes up 6 cents, wholesalers get a nickel, and the service station owner gets
12 cents. Taxes take up the rest.
Here's a Hint: 100
- 34 - 6 - 12 = 48
High-gas-price blues? Blame
the greens. Americans have every right to be angry, as they watch the rising price of gasoline
take a bigger bite out of their paychecks. But their anger should be directed toward the real cause of
the unnecessary price increases: irresponsible reverence for the environment.
Global Warming and the Price of a Gallon of Gas:
You may want to give credit where credit is due to Al Gore and his global warming campaign the next time you fill your
car with gasoline, because there is a direct connection between Global Warming and four dollar a gallon gas. It is
shocking, but true, to learn that the entire Global Warming frenzy is based on the environmentalist's attack on fossil
fuels, particularly gasoline.
What's the Answer for High Gasoline Prices?
Nothing. At the end of the day, the best remedy for high gasoline prices is… high gasoline
prices, which provide all the incentives necessary for motorists to conserve, for oil companies to put more
product into the marketplace, and for investors to look into alternatives fuel technologies. Government
has never demonstrated an ability to do better.
Local, State and Federal Gas Taxes Consume
45.9 Cents Per Gallon on Average. Record gasoline prices are constantly in the headlines, which
leaves many asking why prices are so high. While supply and demand are the primary determinants of
gasoline prices, a significant portion of the price consumers pay at the pump can be attributed to gasoline
taxes. In fact, the federal gas tax alone equals 18.4 cents for every gallon purchased.
Oh, Those 'Enormous and
Unreasonable' Oil Profits. Convenience store operators make their profits
from merchandise sales and gaming machines, not gasoline sales. The gas pumps are
there just to get you into the store. [On the other hand,] the federal tax on
gasoline is 18.4 cents per gallon. The State of Nevada levies an additional
33.7 cents. That's 52.1 cents a gallon going to the government. Residents
of the Silver State pay the third highest gasoline tax in the nation, behind only New York
and Hawaii.
Chafee Votes to Keep Gas Prices
High. Environmentalists opposed [Chairman Jim Inhofe's Gas PRICE Act (S 1772)] for
its provisions to expand refinery capacity, streamline refinery permitting and simplify so-called
boutique fuel requirements. It also would have provided federal assistance for the construction
of refineries on closed military bases, which could have been producing gas in about two years,
Inhofe said.
Statement of Jonathan
Adler before the U.S. Senate Committee on Environment & Public Works: Gasoline
markets' ability to respond to supply disruptions and price changes have been severely hampered
by federal fuel content mandates under the Clean Air Act. Imposing various boutique fuel
mandates on different regions of the country has balkanized domestic gasoline markets and
increased prices for consumers for minimal environmental benefit. By segmenting
national gasoline markets, these requirements have made some regions more vulnerable to supply
disruptions and volatile gasoline prices. Some boutique fuel requirements have further
strained gasoline supplies by reducing the volume of saleable product that can be produced. Yet
since passage of the 1990 Clean Air Act, such mandates have been expanded, not reduced.
Congressional Mandates Contribute
to Higher Gas Prices. Four major components drive the retail price of gasoline: the
cost of crude oil, refinery processing costs (including environmental regulations), distribution and
marketing costs, and taxes. … Distribution and marketing costs [account] for 11 percent of the
retail price of gasoline. The wide variety of specialized regional gasoline formulas required
by federal and state regulators make storage and distribution more difficult and increase the potential
for supply disruptions and short-term price spikes. Moreover, specialized blends required for
one area of the nation may not be suitable for another area. Furthermore, not every refinery
can produce every grade of gasoline and pipelines have limited flexibility to move different grades
of gasoline to different places.
The Gas PRICE
Act: A Modest Step Forward in the Post-Katrina Energy Debate. Sen. James
Inhofe's (R-OK) new energy bill … contains several sections that could help reduce motor fuel
prices over the long term. One would allow states to streamline refinery permitting,
transforming a process that now drags on for years into one that must be completed in
months. This should encourage expansions of existing refineries. By reducing
some of the costs and uncertainties involved in undertaking such projects, these provisions
would facilitate bringing badly-needed additional capacity online.
The case for more
uniform fuel standards: An even bigger concern may be the effect that this market
segmentation has in combination with two other developments. The first is the fact that
over the last quarter century, half the refineries in America have shut down and no new
ones have been built. The second is the number of mergers and acquisitions that
we have seen in the petroleum industry over the same period.
Map of
US Gasoline Requirements. This map shows the nature of the proliferation of fuel
standards. It indicates that you could drive through seven contiguous counties in Arizona,
California, and Nevada, and be required by law to put a different formulation of regular gasoline
in your vehicle in each one.
A Nice Overview of the Problem with
Boutique Fuels. Boutique and reformulated gasolines have balkanized our nation's
gasoline markets, creating virtual islands of gasoline blends that are subject to more severe
price spikes than the rest of the nation.
NACS Voices Fuel
Price Volatility Concerns to Congress. The overlapping federal, state and local
regulations that dictate specific fuel formulations for distinct markets must be replaced with
a more uniform system. A reduction in the number of boutique fuels is essential to
stabilizing both supplies and prices. This need not result in a reduction in
environmental protections.
Chart
shows Boutique Fuel Requirements Across the U.S.. There are more than 300 local and
state fuel regulations in the U.S. These regulations result in a patchwork of gasoline zones
across the country where only certain fuels can be sold, creating price disparities across the
country.

The
Factors Influencing the Price of Gasoline.
Chart:
U.S. Gasoline Distribution System.
Where
Does Your Gas Dollar Go? Most consumers don't know that 90 percent of the price of
gas is determined before it even reaches their local convenience store.
Gasoline
prices: Some Americans are demanding that the government do something about
gasoline prices. Let's think back to 1979 when the government did do something. The
Carter administration instituted price controls. What did we see? We saw long
gasoline lines, and that's if the gas station hadn't run out of gas. It's estimated
that Americans used about 150,000 barrels of oil per day idling their cars while waiting
in line.
Why High Gas Prices? When
three socialist amigos like Senators Charles Sch